Before You Read...

I have never written a book before and I'm not going to act like I know how. These chapters are rough drafts of what I hope becomes a novel. I realize there are grammar errors, and I'm sure there's a plentitude of them. That's not the most important aspect of writing though (at least not to me). The bulk of writing is about getting thoughts down and that's what I'm doing. I'll edit grammar later.

The working title of the book is The Life of Margaret O'Malley. So you know, this is fiction. And by fiction I mean fabricated and not autobiographical. None of the characters resemble my family members and Maggie's character is not based off my life. There is profanity, uncomfortable situations, stereotyping and references to God. Please take no offense, it's just how I envisioned the characters. The chapters are unique and each one is titled after a song. There will be a line from each song before every chapter begins, revealing a slice of what the chapter is about.

Finally, I am Irish and even though I wished I lived in Ireland, I do not and never have. All references I make are based off research and interest.

Oh, and if you steal my work and publish it as your own, I will hunt you down. That is all.

Please give these chapters a read and leave any comments and feedback you have. You have no idea how much your thoughts will help me! The chapters are listed in the side column. :)

Sunday, September 20, 2009

I'm so tired of writing about religion-- I don't have the answers...

Lindsay Hutton
Honors 101
Dr. Mahn

Uncertainty

“Cause everybody has a part in the game,
Everyone’s got a cross they can claim,
And everybody’s got somebody to blame,
But we all must find our own way.”
-Amos Lee, from the song, “Shout Out Loud”

In a world of many different religions, a strong believer in any paradigm of religious thought struggles everyday with the pressures of righteousness resulting from comparing and accepting different faiths. Due to the constant battle of change and tolerance, religious patrons tend to view their religion as the ultimate path to Heaven, Nirvana, and other forms of eternal longevity. Whether recognizing it or not, believers are labeled as exclusive thinkers, which receives much criticism from Diana Eck in Encountering God. However, her critique of exclusivism actually hurts her ultimate goal of proving pluralism as the only true way of “encountering God.” In her book, Eck addresses the issues of exclusivism and pluralism regarding common religious thought. As the methods of recognizing religious tolerance are discussed, Eck creates confliction between the approaches and what paradigms of thought lay out the correct path to salvation, thus opening her stances for contention.

In the eyes of an exclusivist thinker, the mere idea of accepting another faith seems unacceptable and virtually insolent toward their own religion. Eck harshly criticizes the exclusivist method of thinking, describing it as, “ethnic or religious chauvinism” (Eck 176). In many cases, her description holds true. For instance, Adolf Hitler thought exclusively that the Arian race was supreme and his ideals were absolute. His process of thinking was indeed, chauvinistic, evil and wrong. When applied to religion - many devout patrons often think of their belief as absolute righteousness - the approach of exclusive thought directly compares to the mindset of Hitler. Evidently, exclusivism represents close-mindedness and inappropriate judgments about many different life practices, including religion. The problem with Eck’s critique is that exclusivism is a result of the misconceptions of pluralism.

The question of whether or not God is listening or even exists still lacks an answer and neither exclusivism nor pluralism can fundamentally provide an answer. Eck sides with pluralism in the excerpt “Is Our God Listening?” and states “people of different religious traditions do not live apart, but are in constant interaction and need, if anything, to be in more intentional inter-related.” However, her view of this inter-relation is purely optimistic. In reality, the acceptance of different faiths rarely happens. Take America for example, the majority of people automatically assume all Muslims are terrorists. While this is not true by any means, the fact of the matter remains prevalent in the world in which people live. There will always be arguments about the correct path of salvation, which faith is more evil and the epistemological uncertainty of religion will never change. Thus, Eck’s hope of universal acceptance by different paradigms lacks practicality. As Wendell Berry states in The Way of Ignorance, “There are questions we must live with, regarding them as unanswerable…” (Berry 130). Due to the uncertainty of religion, one will always be an exclusivist thinker even if he thinks of himself as a pluralist.

Eck needs to go farther in her exploratory piece. In order for her stance on pluralism to be inherently valid, she must address the fact that each religion will never stand united with another; there is no common ground like Eck tries to say. There are different heavens and completely dissimilar modes of living within each individual faith. Rather than agreeing with pluralism, she needs to look at the paradigm for what it truly means and how the effects of being a pluralist actual hurt one’s relationship with his religion. In fact, the only way for a person to be truly pluralist is to step back and disregard their religion. It goes against the majority of faiths to view and accept other methods of belief as true. Thus, one who is devoted to his religion cannot be anything but exclusive. Pluralism just presents the thought that in a perfect world, people would all understand and respect each other’s religions; however, the acceptance of diverse beliefs will never be reached despite attempts like Eck’s.

Every person in the world must find their own way of thinking when it comes to religion. Many people will try to classify methods of thinking regarding religious acceptance. Yet, in reality, people will always believe their paradigm of thought is intrinsically correct; it is human nature. Eck’s paradigm of pluralism leads people to be exclusive because betrayal of their religion ultimately means no salvation and thus no heaven. If people actually thought of themselves as pluralists, they would have to believe that there is more than one heaven. And by accepting those different forms of heaven, it enhances one’s faith rather than goes against it, but this is not how Eck describes pluralism. Realistically, there are probably many perpetual afterlives. Still, in order to grasp this pluralistic view, one must believe that there is more than one right answer to the questions of who God is and if he listens. The only way to really believe this is by being Agnostic. One cannot be Catholic and say, “I believe in my God, and your God, and Buddha.” It goes against his religious teachings. One cannot be a pluralist and have a strong faith like Eck wants people to believe. He must find his own way and choose to either follow one God or accept the idea of pluralism - believing in a higher power but not actually knowing which God actually leads to salvation - and be satisfied with the uncertainty either way. “Religion, it’s a big decision, but we’re all in this together,” the method of finding the right one, that is.

No comments: