Before You Read...

I have never written a book before and I'm not going to act like I know how. These chapters are rough drafts of what I hope becomes a novel. I realize there are grammar errors, and I'm sure there's a plentitude of them. That's not the most important aspect of writing though (at least not to me). The bulk of writing is about getting thoughts down and that's what I'm doing. I'll edit grammar later.

The working title of the book is The Life of Margaret O'Malley. So you know, this is fiction. And by fiction I mean fabricated and not autobiographical. None of the characters resemble my family members and Maggie's character is not based off my life. There is profanity, uncomfortable situations, stereotyping and references to God. Please take no offense, it's just how I envisioned the characters. The chapters are unique and each one is titled after a song. There will be a line from each song before every chapter begins, revealing a slice of what the chapter is about.

Finally, I am Irish and even though I wished I lived in Ireland, I do not and never have. All references I make are based off research and interest.

Oh, and if you steal my work and publish it as your own, I will hunt you down. That is all.

Please give these chapters a read and leave any comments and feedback you have. You have no idea how much your thoughts will help me! The chapters are listed in the side column. :)

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Become Alive

"Forwarding" the works of René Descartes and Immanuel Kant to explore the film Stranger than Fiction.

By: Lindsay Hutton, HONR 101, Dr. Mahn

To be a self – to think, to author one’s own life, to let others rule and take precedence, to live without fear, to know when death is approaching, to recognize all the evil and mistakes in the world… to live like tomorrow does not exist. In the film, Stranger than Fiction, the protagonist, Harold Crick, faces the dilemma of living an autonomous lifestyle versus a heteronymous one. At the beginning of the movie, Crick lives his life routinely and without fervor due to the autonomy of his existence. However, as the film progresses, Crick transforms into a man with passion, love and the knowledge of heteronomy taking place in his life. The author of Crick’s newfound existence, Karen Eiffel, becomes known to the protagonist early on in the story. As Crick struggles with psychological aspects of the heteronymous shift in decision making, he inadvertently falls in love and exposes his true personality which resembles nothing of his lackluster past. Human qualities like laughter, love, bravery, happiness, and passion actually create freedom for Crick. Heteronomy allows a person to take chances and enables him to make decisions without fear of failure. Autonomy, on the other hand, leads to self-deprecation, ridicule from others and potentially inner destruction.

In Stranger than Fiction, Harold Crick lives a mundane existence of habit and exhibits no signs of happiness or ardor for the challenges and experiences in his life; similar to the life of a slave to the machine. That is, until his autonomous, customary being changes before his eyes. Now controlled by another author, Crick must choose to willfully accept the emergence of heteronomy in his life or ignore the narration and simply go on living in the same way he had for years. Recognizing that heteronomy leads him to his love and passions, Crick eventually decides to embrace the alteration of his life. Since his personality awakening, the protagonist looks at life with a new set of eyes. He breaks the solitary chains of his soul and liberates his true spirit. Before heteronomy took effect in Crick’s life, he lived without purpose besides to audit people and simply imagine how his life could be more exciting. Furthermore, if a life lacks purpose and action, is it a life worth living? This question embodies Eiffel’s attitude towards the character of Harold Crick. After he develops his true individuality, the author states that “he does not deserve to die” and prior to his awakening, Eiffel had no reservations regarding his demise. To be a self, requires human qualities in order to fully engage in the exuberance of life. Crick develops these characteristics through the evolution of the film and makes the pivotal step in truly becoming a unique and valued self. At the end of the movie, Crick risks his life to save that of another; not because the author told him to, but because the author instilled the characteristics of a caring, brave and passionate individual within him. Hence, heteronomy has the capability of inspiring people to recognize their potential for living and a life with purpose, potential and passion is indubitably priceless.

The remarkable transformation that takes place in Stranger than Fiction not only pertains to the film, but to millions of people across the globe. Being dependent or living heteronomously tends to receive negative connotations; however, relying on another’s words, opinions, and thoughts justly demonstrates what it means to be a self. Marriage - a brave pursuit sought out by nearly half of the world’s population requires human characteristics. The concept of marriage joins two selves and unites them into one. In order for a person to be a self, he or she must recognize that dependency does not equal insufficiency or irrationality like Kant describes in On History. Rather, the act justifies just the opposite. The duties of human beings are to recognize that they need one another to survive. The notion that one can live completely in isolation without any regard to the outside world is ludicrous. To embrace the unknown and go forward in life with another person represents the whole theory of Enlightenment. Kant would disagree, but Descartes links this idea in Meditations on Philosophy. Descartes abandons all knowledge in hopes of realizing some unknown aspect of life. When two people get married, they must start from ground zero and realize that their lives will be infinitely different than they had been before the commitment. As an Enlightened thinker, Descartes epitomizes the fact that people must welcome the idea of misinterpretations made by oneself. His famous line, “I know nothing, not even that,” tremendously symbolizes that humans make mistakes and therefore must begin to reconstruct their way of living as well as their way of thinking, just as married couples do. If making this commitment to another means jumping into an unknown world, then so be it.

Bravery and risk taking represents human nature and what it means to be a self. Descartes took a risk by defying the idea that God exists. However, he made the leap and was not afraid of the consequences. As a Catholic, Descartes may have challenged God, but he ultimately led a life heteronomously under God’s will. Due to this, he was not afraid to take chances in order to live a more enlightened life. Just because Kant argues autonomous living is the only way to live and be a rational, enlightened thinker does not make his contention valid. There is proof not only in Descartes writings and on the modern silver screen, but in life in general with the example of marriage that heteronomy actual enables one to live a more enlightened existence. The foundation of autonomy relies on the fact that self-knowledge is more important than the laws of others; yet this narcissist attitude is not absolute and can be ill-fated. If Harold Crick were to continue to live his life autonomously, he would have made a fatal mistake; as Eiffel would have killed him because of his mundane, self-ruling lifestyle. Also, history shows other generations that living autonomously has its consequences. Julius Caesar believed that he was the supreme ruler of Rome until this self-absorption sparked the minds of others and eventually led to his assassination. Caesar was never truly free, he was a dictator and the peasants who lived heteronomously underneath him were the truly enlightened and liberated souls. Brutus recited to the crowd after Caesar’s demise, “People of Rome, we are free!” If the people of Rome had lived autonomously, Caesar’s reign would have lasted much longer than it did. Caesar, however, thought he would rule until old age, yet he never took into account the power of a liberated, heteronymous population. By relying on another to write the story of life, or to lead the assassination of a brutal dictator, or to give words of advice in pressing times, allows a person to fully experience life – the foundation of Enlightenment.

To live a life with the help of another truly represents freedom. It allows a person to be who they are no matter what - no basis of self-authority or narcissism - completely and utterly individualistic with ideals that represent humanity. It requires human traits to live a heteronymous lifestyle and mechanical traits to live autonomously. To exist with human characteristics, to recognize the existence of others and embrace their opinions, to understand what it is like to live dependently, to have passion, to be brave, to admire the beauty of thought, to realize potential and have no fear of chasing it - to live is to be a self.

2 comments:

Katherine Schutte said...

You are amazing.

Lindsay said...

thanks :)

this was a struggle at first... haven't gotten a grade back yet. hopefully, it turns out well!